Refusing a Root Canal – Is a Simple Filling Enough to Save Your Tooth?

August 25, 2025

If your dentist has recommended a root canal, you might be wondering if you can simply refuse it and get a filling instead. The short answer: it depends on the condition of your tooth. 


A dental filling only works when decay hasn’t reached the inner pulp of the tooth. Once infection sets in, a root canal is usually the only way to save the tooth. Refusing it could mean ongoing pain, spreading infection, or eventually losing the tooth altogether.


Why a Filling May Not Be Enough

Fillings repair surface-level cavities by replacing the decayed part of the tooth. But if bacteria have already reached the pulp (where the nerves and blood vessels live), a filling won’t stop the infection. In fact, covering it up could make things worse because the infection is trapped inside.


What Happens If You Skip a Root Canal

  • Pain may continue or get worse
  • Infection can spread to gums, bone, or even other teeth
  • You may need an extraction later, which can be more complex (and costly)


You can refuse a root canal, but your dentist will likely explain that a filling won’t fix the problem if the tooth is infected. In most cases, it’s root canal or tooth extraction.


Talking openly with your dentist about fears, costs, and alternatives is the best way to make a confident decision.


At Alpine Dental, patients trust our team for gentle, expert care. Whether you need a routine filling, emergency dental treatment, or advanced solutions like dental implants and veneers, we’re here to help keep your smile healthy. 


Looking for the best dentist in New Jersey? Alpine Dental is ready to care for you.


FAQs



  • 1. Can I get a filling instead of a root canal?

    Only if the decay hasn’t reached the pulp. Once infection is present, a filling won’t work.


  • 2. What’s the risk of refusing a root canal?

    You could face severe pain, spreading infection, or tooth loss.


  • 3. Is extraction better than a root canal?

    Extraction removes the problem tooth but often leads to replacement costs later. A root canal usually saves your natural tooth.


Sources:


  • https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/22120-tooth-extraction
  • https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/21759-root-canal
  • https://mypenndentist.org/our-services/endodontics/do-i-need-a-root-canal-or-filling/
  • https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/007630.htm
  • https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK589654/
  • https://www.aae.org/patients/root-canal-treatment/what-is-a-root-canal/



Need Expert Dental Care? We’re Here for You

At Alpine Dental NJ, we prioritize your oral health and comfort. Our experienced team offers personalized, high-quality dental care to help you achieve a confident, healthy smile.

Book your appointment today and experience exceptional dental care.

Schedule Your Visit
Woman flossing her teeth in front of a mirror.
October 4, 2025
Floss, brush, or mouthwash—what’s the best order? Dentists recommend a sequence that improves cavity prevention, removes plaque, and boosts your smile.
Person flossing their teeth with dental floss.
October 4, 2025
Learn how to care for dental veneers with brushing tips, flossing, and dentist-approved habits. Keep your veneers strong, stain-free, and long-lasting.
Woman smiling during a dental check-up with dentist’s hand holding a tool.
October 4, 2025
Dental crowns restore and protect weak teeth. Explore the main crown types, how long they last, and which materials work best for front and back teeth.